Calcutta HC Rejects Mandatory Vande Mataram Stanzas in Madrassas
+AI Analysis - Key Points
- 01
The Calcutta HC ruled that making Vande Mataram mandatory in madrassas could disrupt communal harmony.
- 02
The court questioned the Centre's jurisdiction in issuing a notification enforcing the mandatory inclusion of all six stanzas.
- 03
The HC observed that no coercive steps have been taken against individuals who refuse to sing Vande Mataram.
The Calcutta high court has rejected a public interest litigation challenging the mandatory inclusion of six stanzas of Vande Mataram in madrassas. Acting Chief Justice Tapabrata Chakraborty observed that making Vande Mataram mandatory could disrupt communal harmony and infringe upon individual freedom. The court questioned the Centre's jurisdiction in issuing a notification enforcing the mandatory inclusion of all six stanzas, citing the Constitution's adoption of only two stanzas. The HC also noted that no coercive steps have been taken against individuals who refuse to sing Vande Mataram. Senior advocate Bikash Ranjan Bhattacharyya, representing the PIL litigant, argued that the mandatory inclusion of all six stanzas would be unconstitutional and could lead to imprisonment for those who refuse to sing. The Additional Solicitor General opposed the demand for an interim prayer to stay the notification, claiming that PILs are being filed for publicity purposes.
The Calcutta HC's ruling has sparked debate on the issue, with multiple PILs filed on the matter. In one of the PILs, senior advocate Kalyan Banerjee submitted that there was debate on the issue in Parliament. The Centre's notification has been met with opposition, with concerns raised over the potential disruption of communal harmony and the infringement upon individual freedom.

The Calcutta HC's decision is a significant development in the ongoing debate over the mandatory inclusion of Vande Mataram in madrassas. The court's ruling has implications for the Centre's jurisdiction and the potential consequences for individuals who refuse to sing Vande Mataram.
VideoVideo Coverage
Calcutta HC Rejects Mandatory Vande Mataram Stanzas in Madrassas
Watch video coverage on YouTube
Opens relevant video results on YouTube.