Punjab Defies SC Decree on 60-Year-Old Power Dispute
+AI Analysis - Key Points
- 01
Punjab has been defying a Supreme Court decree on a 60-year-old power dispute between Himachal Pradesh and Punjab.
- 02
The court has expressed frustration with Punjab's resistance and warned of consequences if the state does not comply.
- 03
A mutually workable settlement framework has been proposed to settle the dispute through in-kind settlement of energy arrears.
The Supreme Court has expressed frustration with Punjab's resistance to a 15-year-old decree settling a 60-year-old power dispute between Himachal Pradesh and Punjab. The court has given Punjab until August 12 to comply with the decree. The dispute dates back to 1966, when Punjab was divided and Himachal Pradesh was formed. The Supreme Court passed the decree in 2011, but Punjab has been defying it ever since. The court has warned Punjab that it will not allow the state to be deprived of the fruits of the decree, and has given it until August 12 to comply. A mutually workable settlement framework has been proposed to settle the dispute through in-kind settlement of energy arrears. This framework would allow the respective claims and liabilities to be adjusted through in-kind settlement of energy arrears and set-off of capital cost liability, thereby obviating the need for any direct financial transaction between the states. Senior advocates Kapil Sibal and Balbir Singh, appearing for Himachal and Haryana, respectively, have agreed to the settlement proposal. However, senior advocate Nidhesh Gupta, appearing for Punjab, has expressed concerns over the workability of the proposal and said that the state would stand to lose substantially if it is implemented. The court has posted the matter for hearing on August 12.
The Supreme Court's frustration with Punjab's resistance is not new. In its July 30 order, the bench said, "Your state has a habit of defying decrees..." The court has been trying to resolve the dispute for years, but Punjab's resistance has hindered progress. The court has now given Punjab a final chance to comply with the decree, and it remains to be seen whether the state will finally comply.

VideoVideo Coverage
Punjab Defies SC Decree on 60-Year-Old Power Dispute
Watch video coverage on YouTube
Opens relevant video results on YouTube.